Overall rating: 4.0738916 / 5 from 203 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Kate Pull On boots are crafted from premium materials, offering a blend of artisanal stitching and everyday wearability. They feature a round toe, cushioned footbed for comfort, and a sturdy rubber outsole with a chunky block heel for stability. The boots are versatile, pairing well with midi skirts or straight-leg denim. However, opinions on sizing and quality vary, with some customers finding the fit true to size and others recommending a larger size. The leather is praised for its softness and comfort, though some find it plastic-like. The style and color are highly appreciated, but the heel and calf fit have mixed reviews.

Summary topics

  • Sizing (9%): Opinions vary on the size, with some finding it true to size and others recommending buying a larger size.
  • Leather Comfort (14%): Customers keep praising the beautiful, soft, and comfortable banana leather boots that fit true to size.
  • Fit (20%): Many customers expressed appreciation for the perfect fit of the boots, mentioning that they fit perfectly and true to size.
  • Style (6%): Customers loved the style of these vintage Frye's, praising their perfect fit and comfort.
  • Color (9%): Customers raved about the color, describing it as beautiful, perfect, and better than expected.

Review topics: ["color","feel","fit","problem","quality","leather","look","boots","size","style","details","calf","stitching","craftsmanship","socks","pulled","frye","made","pair","arch","suede","shaft","break","version","sweater","control","chocolate","calf area","deal","side"].

Review highlights

  • "Frye is so high quality and the Kate's to me are the timeless look I've been searching for." — Deena N.
  • "Banana is much better color in person and is more neutral makes the boots look great with just about everything." — Lucie
  • "The fit is perfect and feels comfortable right out of the box, with no break-in period needed." — Carrie A.

Reviews

Really gorgeous boots. I purchased

"Really gorgeous boots. I purchased my first pair of Fryes in 1979; have had many since. These boots are very wide in the calf circumference: stated on website is 14.5". True measurements is 17" . My legs aren't skinny;these are a wee bit floppy. I love them even even so."

— Kathleen P. (4/5)

"The color was quite different in person. Hardly gold in any light other than very warm. Should probably be called “metallic black”. The leather did feel a bit lower quality than other Frye items I’ve had-and the paint on the boot is quite flakey. The return process is very convenient, thankfully."

— Timmie (2/5)

"I’ve worn these only 3 times and the yellow has already rubbed off. I think that’s really unacceptable for the amount of money these cost… Really sad because it’s a cute boot"

— Makayla (2/5)

Terrible customer service and exchange policy.

"I bought a pair of these boots while on sale in wide calf, turns out I didn’t need wide calf despite following the measurements provided in the sizing chart. Apparently you can not exchange a wide calf to normal calf and expect them to honor a sale price even though both items have identical pricing and were both on sale for the same price. I would recommend going to a real store where they will gladly honor sales prices for exchanges. Not this money hungry greedy retailer."

— Brandon. (1/5)

"Trying to stretch the right boot. I have a bunion that hurt when I first put them on. I had a pair similar to these in college and they were so comfortable, I lived in them!"

— Millie (5/5)

"The are beautiful Fit is perfect"

— Angela (5/5)

color is a bit duller

"color is a bit duller than the pictures show"

— Ashley E. (4/5)

"Beautifully crafted boots! Love Frye💕"

— Joy (5/5)

"Love love love!!!"

— Mariah (5/5)

runs a bit large

"runs a bit large"

— Ashley E. (4/5)

Q&A