Overall rating: 3.909091 / 5 from 44 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Sadie Softy Tall boot offers a stylish and comfortable knee-high option with premium materials and an easy-to-use side closure. While opinions on fit and size vary, the boot's versatile design makes it suitable for various outfits.

Summary topics

  • Fit: 32%
  • Size: 24%

Review topics: ["size","fit","color","price","look","quality","customer service","boots","height","leather","socks","calf","toe","pair","feet","room"].

Review highlights

  • "The boots were for my girlfriend, they fit perfect and look great."Maria
  • "5 and thankfully they fit perfectly!"Kelly B.
  • "5 is perfect - I recommend sizing up at least 1/2 to a full size."Rachel

Reviews

This is my 3rd pair

"This is my 3rd pair of Fryes and my second high shaft and Frye has never disappointed me yet! My usual size is 7. 5 but I have wider feet so I almost always size up to an 8 and I always size up in my fryes. The size 8 was perfect but I would need to go up to 8. 5 if I wanted to wear thicker socks. The suede is so soft the heel height is perfect the bottoms are rubber which is a necessity for me (I have Melissa two buttons that I ended up taking to a cobbler for rubber soles). The calf is on the tighter end but not any different than any other riding style boots I own but if your calf’s are even slightly on the thicker side you definitely need a wide calf in this boot."

Michelle H. (5/5)

Boots goes well with lots

"Boots goes well with lots of outfits. Boots runs small. Buy 1/2 to one size bigger than your normal size. I have narrow feet and it’s tight in the feet area. Im a regular size 8 with frye and these were tight with very thin socks."

t f. (5/5)

The sizing is extremely inaccurate

"The sizing is extremely inaccurate in these boots. I own other Frye shoes and wear my normal size. These boots are at least 1 whole size if not more smaller than noted. Very disappointing that the company would sell such a product."

Amy C. (1/5)

These boots have a great

"These boots have a great silhouette. The leather is nice, they are a great color and look great on. The only thing is the shaft is wider than they say on the description"

Richard M. (5/5)

I was disappointed because I

"I was disappointed because I love this boots but I was advised to size-up because they run big (I’m a 7. 5) so I ordered an 8 and they feel huge! Wish I could exchange but its as final sale."

Morgan W. (1/5)

These are my favorite boots

"These are my favorite boots ever. They are so comfortable. They are perfect height. Can wear them with a cute dress or jeans. Will be perfect in the spring with some shirts. Will definitely order from this company again"

Angela C. (5/5)

Always quality always excellent customer

"Always quality always excellent customer service always willing to help."

JANICE J. (5/5)

Absolutely beautiful. Fit perfectly and

"Absolutely beautiful. Fit perfectly and they are comfortable to wear. I wear a 7 but ordered a 7. 5 after reading the reviews, great advice."

Elizabeth M. (5/5)

The boot is beautiful and

"The boot is beautiful and very comfortable! I am so glad that I found these!! I went up 1/2 size so that i could wear a sock."

Virginia G. (5/5)

Please make a narrow calf size option, Frye!

"Pretty boots that are tall enough for my long legs (I’m 5’9), but unfortunately also extremely wide in the calf so I won’t be able to wear them. Footbed is on the narrow side but this wasn’t an issue for me as I have narrow feet. I am bummed that these were final sale as they are not wearable. Please consider making narrow calf sizes, Frye!"

Caitlin (3/5)

Q&A