Overall rating: 4.3333335 / 5 from 21 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Tyler Flex Penny combines comfort and craftsmanship with a durable construction and a new rubber outsole. Customers appreciate its great fit and stylish look, making it versatile for both formal and casual outfits.

Summary topics

  • Fit: 35%
  • Look: 30%

Review topics: ["fit","quality","look","shoes","style","frye","loafers"].

Review highlights

  • "great fit, great Frye quality great look"George G.
  • "Love the feel, the smell, good weight to them with a nice heel."Alex H.
  • "The quality is awesome and they look great"Brian

Reviews

These shoes are incredibly well

"These shoes are incredibly well made and stylish. 12 out of 10!!"

Dewayne K. (5/5)

Small, stiff, and stupid

"This shoe is super stiff. I’ve got a bunch of Frye and I’ve always worn the same size (perfect fit) but I have trouble even getting my feet in these and after I do the tow box is tiny and uncomfortable. The tread section is also much smaller and tippy than it needs to be. Strongly recommend against. These are tied with another pair for the worst fryes I’ve ever tried."

Ehran (1/5)

The quality of leather is

"The quality of leather is great and stands up to its mark. The style is very trendy and fits perfectly to its size."

Anant S. (5/5)

great fit, great Frye quality

"great fit, great Frye quality great look"

George G. (5/5)

Love the feel, the smell,

"Love the feel, the smell, good weight to them with a nice heel. Beautiful leather & workmanship, gives me not only a bit of height but confidence in knowing this is a good looking shoe. Can be dressed up for business business or chilling how ever ya wanna go. . sock less. . jeans. . ? All good 👌🏽One thing I found very unfortunate, they won’t actually hold a penny, these deserve a quarter. Have to keep a penny in them for good luck."

Alex H. (5/5)

Frye does not disappoint with

"Frye does not disappoint with the Tyler Flex Penny. Quality made, perfect fit. My only observation is the cut of the toe is a little pointed. I usually keep shoe trees in my shoes so, it curling up should not be a problem. Great style! I can't wait to start wearing."

Byron P. (5/5)

Beautiful color and comfortable. Needs

"Beautiful color and comfortable. Needs a bit of breaking in, though. Found my regular size of10. 5 too large, had to size down."

Angelika H. (5/5)

Shoes look great. They feel

"Shoes look great. They feel a bit narrow at first but they break in nicely. I got a 10, but I'm a small 10, so if you are a 10 with wide feet, I'd suggest going up half a size. Good quality."

Daniel W. (5/5)

Tyler Flex Loafer-Most Comfortable

"The Tyler Flex Loafers are the most comfortable loafers I have. They are very flexible and don't feel like a dress shoe. The leather quality and soles are well made. I'm a true 9. 5 and I had to add a heel pad to prevent a small flop feel. Love these loafers!"

Shark (5/5)

Insole is terrible

"Beautiful shoe, looks like it’s built well. I’ve worn it about 4 times and the insole is detaching from the shoe. This is my 5th pair of Frye shoes/boots. This is a design flaw that needs corrected."

Doyle M. (1/5)

Q&A