False advertising
"The boots I received were made of completely different leather than the boots advertised on the website. The boot shaft is even shaped differently. This is false advertising. Y'all lost a fan."
Women

Overall rating: 4.3768115 / 5 from 138 reviews.
Billy Pull On boots are praised for their excellent quality, sleek style, and perfect fit. Customers appreciate the high-quality leather and craftsmanship, though opinions on color and size vary.
Review topics: ["size","fit","color","problem","look","quality","design","shoes","comfort","weather","style","boots","craftsmanship","construction","leather","pair","foot","calf","heel","frye","pulled","break","vibe","wear","toe","circumference","feet"].
"The boots I received were made of completely different leather than the boots advertised on the website. The boot shaft is even shaped differently. This is false advertising. Y'all lost a fan."
"Beautiful boots. I ordered an 8 and they slipped off my feet. The 7. 5 came back in stock and feel a bit snug through the broadest part of my foot (my foot is a big wide) but I intend to break them in."
"These boots have the most beautiful and versatile brown leather. They can be dressed up or down and will only improve the more you break them in. I love a product that continues to look better as they age. They are made with great care and quality craftsmanship. Love these boots!"
"Great quality"
"They are beautiful and classy. . very comfortable as well! I usually have a hard time with slip on due to my high arches. . but these boots were very easy. ."
"So very cute but run about one size small"
"Love the Billy. I got the black. As per usual with Frye boots there was no break in period. The black is so simple. Just the boot I was looking for. A bit large in the top but I tucked my straight leg jeans in there. Can’t go wrong with this one. Simple and too cute!! Don’t pass up this everyday boot."
"This is my second pair of Frye boots. The black Billy pull on boots are definitely the look I was hoping for. I love the rugged yet sexy look of them. They will go with jeans and dresses. I can’t wait to wear them out with all the Holidays coming up! I love the smell of Frye boots and my older ones still have it. I wear size 8 1/2 and that is what size I purchased and they are great fit. Love when they get worn in and fit like a glove! Highly recommend!!!"
"These boots are way too narrow - I couldn’t get my foot into the calf part of the boot :("
"Very cute and really nice boot, but unfortunately for me, they run a little wide"