Men
Overall rating: 3.125 / 5 from 8 reviews.
Review topics: [color, look, shoes, loafers, pair, woman].
"I ordered this shoe thinking it was women. I filtered on women and then sale. Apparently it does not hold a double filter because the Conner came up with it is a final sale so I am stuck with it. It is a beautiful shoe. I love the women’s pair I received and when I called and explained and wanted to exchange as I only had them 5 minutes I was told, tobad final sale, so be careful. It was order number FRYE- 1180837. I would love to exchange for the ivy in brown"
"Bought these on May 7, 2026. After only one wearing, I noticed that the shoes had stained my yellow socks black. Frye will not accept a return for a full refund because these were marked "Final Sale. " The shoes were never wet nor subject to perspiration. I would get their position if I simply did not like the styling or fit, but these clearly have a defect in manufacturing."
"So below is my review from earlier. Frye makes it sound like they are going to do right but they do not. The shoe is a wonderful shoe. My issue is with their filtering system. When you press women’s it takes you to women’s shoe, then I filter on sale. Lo and behold it bring you back to all shoes which I was unaware of. I was thinking I was buying women’s shoes and I ended up with men’s shoes. I just wanted to exchange for the women’s shoes as it was not my fault as I thought I was buying women’s shoes. They showed up men’s shoes. I wrote the review below. They commented like they were going to help but it was a to bad for you, I ordered this shoe thinking it was women. I filtered on women and then sale. Apparently it does not hold a double filter because the Conner came up with it is a final sale so I am stuck with it. It is a beautiful shoe. I love the women’s pair I received and when I called and explained and wanted to exchange as I only had them 5 minutes I was told, tobad final sale, so be careful. It was order number FRYE- 1180837. I would love to exchange for the ivy in brownRead less Comments by Store Owner on Review by Store Owner on Tue Jul 07 2026 Store Owner Hello Gail, we’re truly sorry to learn about your experience. Our team will be in touch with you shortly."
"I have the light grey suede loafers and the saddle Brown leather loafers. I love them both! I have a narrow foot so these loafers fit me like a glove. They are very comfortable and have a nice classy look and are very high qaulity. I bought them to wear with shorts. I wear a 10. 5 shoe and the size 10 shoe is perfect! 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟"
"Excellent loafers and very well made. Bought 3 different colors. I am 7. 5 and size 8 fits perfectly. Love the chunky heel, gives me an extra inch in height when compared to other loafer brands ;)"
"I have been shopping Frye boots for a year now and I already have 6 pairs. Once you start enjoying the craftsmanship and materials used in Frye shoes, there is no going back. This pair is already the best loafer in collection. Thanks, Frye team !"
"Very narrow toe box"
"Very well made product that fit true to size. A comfortable shoe that I was able to wear without socks as is my preference without getting any blisters. I will say the chocolate color is one or two shades darker than appear in the photo on this site, but I'm hoping they'll fade just a little over time as I liked the more caramel color the site portrayed. Overall very satisfied!"
