Women
Overall rating: 4.361111 / 5 from 144 reviews.
The Faith Loafer combines classic style with comfort, featuring premium leather, a cushioned insole, and a lightweight rubber outsole. Customers praise its exceptional fit, beautiful color, and high quality, though some noted it runs small.
Review topics: [size, fit, color, support, style, design, weight, problem, feel, look, quality, shoes, comfort, leather, width, loafers, loafer, break, heel, suede, feet, boots, socks, cost, work, shipping].
"I ordered these loafers back in December 2025 for my wife. After 8 months of use (in dry conditions) the soles are now coming off of the upper portion of the loafer. Be warned that these are not durable and the life expectancy is very low, especially for the price of the loafer."
"I wanted to love these shoes so much. . . but the sizing is wildly inconsistent. I have tried two size 8s and an 8. 5. One had a mismatched pair, and the two 8's fit completely differently. If you want to give them a shot, I would recommend buying from a company with free shipping and returns, because it may take a few tries, and the $12 return fee Frye charges adds up quick and makes it an extra unpleasant surprise when the sizing is all over the place. Personally, I'm just done with Frye, there's other companies that make similar styles but offer way better customer support and consistency across products. This company is not conducive to online shopping. The Heather ballet is even crazier with sizing. Frye needs to get their QC under control."
"The shoes have more of a reddish color not a dark brown"
"Extremely comfortable shoe. I love the pink shade and the sueded leather. They're a great walking shoe with no break-in period needed. The interior is very soft and causes no rubbing or irritation."
"Beautiful shoe but absolutely no arch support. Very delicate goat suede; don’t expect it to last well. Also irritated that i had to pay $ shipping to myself as well as returning. Not good customer service like other companies"
"Terrible quality, so disappointing."
"These loafers are the exact ones I had been searching for! The leather is supple and soft, they slip on easily and require no break-in time. I am a solid 8 and the 8 fit perfectly, however I do not wear socks with these. If you plan on wearing socks, you may need to size up a half size. I received so many compliments, and will be ordering another pair!"
"I love these loafers so much! They are a classic shoe that will go with anything. Frye makes amazing quality shoes and these are super comfortable. I feel like I’m wearing slippers all day. I love them and will definitely buy another color"
"These are so comfortable! Soft leather, true to size, and feel great to walk in. Def recommend!"
"Ordered half size up due to being narrow, and they fit great. Very comfortable and versatile"
