Overall rating: 3.792683 / 5 from 82 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Kate Pull On Wide Calf riding boots are crafted from premium materials, featuring artisanal woodstock stitching and a cushioned footbed for comfort. They offer a sturdy rubber outsole and a chunky block heel for stability. While many customers appreciate the great look and true-to-size fit, opinions on quality and calf comfort vary.

Summary topics

  • Material Quality (21%): Customers have mixed opinions about the quality, with some praising it and others finding it poor.
  • Leather Quality (19%): Many customers expressed appreciation for the good quality and luxurious smell of the leather used in the product.
  • Toe Box Comfort (9%): Customers expressed differing viewpoints regarding the toe box, with some finding it narrow and uncomfortable, while others found it wide and comfortable.
  • Calf Comfort (16%): The feedback is varied, with some customers finding the boots comfortable and flattering, while others experienced sizing issues.
  • Aesthetic Appeal (16%): Many customers expressed appreciation for the great look of these boots, mentioning that they look fabulous and flattering.

Review topics: ["size","fit","color","problem","look","style","feel","addition","design","quality","comfort","pair","leather","width","craftsmanship","boots","calf","toe","smell","version","fall","campus","room","shoes","wear","made","feet","arch","control"].

Review highlights

  • "Thank you Frye for GREAT quality boots that look and feel amazing!!!"Lila
  • "Amazing fit and quality!"April C.
  • "Comfortable fit for large calves"Alyssa M.

Reviews

Good luck with exchange

"Hopefully you know exactly what size you are if you buy something on sale. Tried to make an exchange from wide calf to normal calf within 15 minutes of delivery of this boot, both were on sale at the time of purchase, however they refuse to honor sale price for exchanging to a different size. Unlike every other online retailer I’ve ever dealt with. Terrible customer service. They’re “sorry” though."

Brandon (1/5)

Terrible quality. I could have

"Terrible quality. I could have bought these at target for 1/3 the price. I returned them."

April S. (1/5)

Wide Calf Approved

"I've searched so long for a cute pair of knee-high boots that fit my wide calfs and I'm so glad I found these. The leather does stretch over time so even though they were a little tight at the cuff for me at first now they fit great with plenty of room!"

Meagan (5/5)

I have waiting years to

"I have waiting years to convince myself I needed and deserved these boots. Well the time came and I purchased them for my birthday. All I can say is, DON'T wait forever like did! I could have been enjoying these extremely high quality crafted boots years ago but I'm happy to have them now. I will 1000% order myself a black pair next and I'm not waiting years to do so."

Tangela S. (5/5)

Not worth the price

"These boots are definitely high quality, but the foot and toe area is quite tight even with a lot of wear. It causes foot pain, and for nearly $400 boots you’d think they’d be a little more comfortable. Unfortunately I’ve found more comfortable ones at Walmart."

Alexandra (3/5)

Love this boot! Beautiful color,

"Love this boot! Beautiful color, construction, and design. I always get a ton of compliments when wearing these! A++ Frye, this boot is a winner in every way."

Lisa T. (5/5)

Love this style!

"I love these boots. They fit perfectly and are true to size. Very comfortable. I would definitely recommend them to others."

Vanessa C. (5/5)

Cute but fall apart

"BOOTS FALL APART! Like some of the other reviews, do not buy these boots, invest in a different brand. I have had these boots for a year and they have completely fallen apart. Soles have come off of both boots (superglued back on currently) and the heel on the inside has broken down and is shlepping off some sort of wool lining layer in the shoe. It is a bummer because the rest of the boot is holding up nicely, just not the part that really matters."

Anna (1/5)

Boot sizes are different

"I was so excited to receive my Kate boots but there was an issue with the fit. The right boot was smaller than the left. The left is loose and the right is too narrow. The leather equality is good but does not match the price. I have a pair of Lucky Brand Hibiscus boots in black that are just as good but much cheeper."

Sharon E. (3/5)

Love these boots

"Love these boots"

Marie J. (5/5)

Q&A