Overall rating: 4.1621623 / 5 from 37 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Melissa Lug Chelsea booties are crafted from premium materials and feature a Frye Melissa button for distinction. The thick, buttery leather and cushioned insole ensure comfort, while the ankle-height shaft and round toe offer versatility for everyday wear. Many customers appreciated the fit, describing it as beautiful and high quality.

Summary topics

  • Product Fit (18%): Many customers appreciated the fit of the product, mentioning that it fit beautifully and was of high quality.
  • Leather Quality (11%): Customers loved the thick and buttery soft leather, which was described as thick, buttery, and comfortable.

Review topics: [].

Review highlights

  • "Love the leater, the color and the fit."Sladjana D.
  • "The leather is thick and buttery soft."Lynne B.
  • "Otherwise, I like the fit and the look."Diane D.

Reviews

Gorgeous but narrow

"This boot is one of the most beautiful Chelsea boots I have ever tried on - which made it even harder for me to accept that they are too narrow. Exceptionally soft and well-crafted, the dark reddish brown is SOOOO BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Perfect for day and night. But alas, they are too narrow. I would KILL for these to come in a wide."

Ali (4/5)

I love Frye Chelsea boos.

"I love Frye Chelsea boos. This is my third pair, not because I wear them down, but because I needed more colors :P still wear all three! I wish they still made the Melissa with a leather sole, but I’ll take the lug. One thing that bugs me with this pair is that the shaft is a little shorter, making it look a little less slim. I did have to put quite a bit of work into stretching them to fit perfectly (width) which I didn’t have to do with the regular Melissas. Not sure what the deal is there. Anyways, the leather is great quality, so it wasn’t a big deal. Just a few days with a stretcher"

Lucja L. (5/5)

After sending me a pair

"After sending me a pair of boots that weren’t even close to true size, and telling me there was no way to exchange them, I won’t be doing business with Frye any more. In today’s world, I am only going to do business with companies who treat their customers right."

Carolyn L. (1/5)

I do wish these Chelsea

"I do wish these Chelsea boots had a "softer sounding heel". They seem a bit loud. like clomping on our hard wood floors. Otherwise, I like the fit and the look."

Diane D. (5/5)

I am disappointed they are

"I am disappointed they are not made in Mexico. My Frye boots that are made there are beautiful. This pair is made in India and looks like synthetic leather. The quality is not the same. I will think twice before buying Frye boots again. Please note that I've been wearing them for 15 years. This is the first time I've doubted the quality and felt really disappointed."

Elissa B. (2/5)

Love them! So beautifully made

"Love them! So beautifully made and comfortable all day!"

Christine S. (5/5)

Quality is very good but

"Quality is very good but the design, especially the front, is not attractive. It looks huge for the size that I ordered. I wanted to return the merchandise, unfortunately it was on final sale. Am so disappointed with my purchase."

Esther D. (1/5)

Runs big

"Runs big"

Mia S. (4/5)

Love the leater, the color

"Love the leater, the color and the fit. very comfortable. Two renarks about how to improve them - dont care for the shape of the strechy part, too low and wider on the lower part - the cushion could be and shoukd be more soft and feet shaped."

Sladjana D. (4/5)

So more and a accurate

"So more and a accurate info neededto make an informed decision b4 ordering. I reached out to Frye for input about sizing, didn’t hear back so made my best decision based on limited review info. Boots are too big. A pricey mistake. Final sale means they don’t have any reason to work w me"

Colette S. (2/5)

Q&A