Overall rating: 3.7169812 / 5 from 53 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Sadie Softy Mid ankle booties are highly praised for their exceptional quality and premium materials. Customers appreciate the soft, supple leather and the stylish chunky block heel. However, sizing can be tricky, with recommendations to buy half to a full size up.

Summary topics

  • Product Quality: 13%
  • Leather Softness: 18%
  • Sizing Recommendations: 15%

Review topics: ["size","fit","color","boots","look","quality","design","heel","leather","height","toe","foot","top","feet"].

Review highlights

  • "This is a beautiful boot and it looks beautiful once you get it on very tough to get on even with a half size larger."Mari D.
  • "Soft buttery leather and comfy heels for all day walking."Jenn V.
  • "Timeless style, soft leather and the quality Frye is known for!"Chel S.

Reviews

They are elegant yet can

"They are elegant yet can dress down and wear with anything. The color is perfect. So comfortable and yet fit like a glove!!"

Jan E. (5/5)

Terrible terrible! I bought a

"Terrible terrible! I bought a pair for my daughter and for me and they are the worst fit that Frye has ever made and I have 13 pairs of boots by Frye."

Angee B. (1/5)

BEAUTIFUL boot. I cannot wait

"BEAUTIFUL boot. I cannot wait to wear these once the weather cools down. I sized up 1/2 size, from a 7. 5 to an 8, which was perfect. I'm not sure how comfortable these will be for walking, but they will be great for work or dinner."

Victoria Y. (4/5)

Sized up a full size

"Sized up a full size and they fit great. Super comfortable."

Shannon M. (5/5)

I like these a lot

"I like these a lot - they're very comfortable and I can't wait to wear them more."

Courtney J. (4/5)

Beautiful boots! They definitely run

"Beautiful boots! They definitely run small-- I normally wear an 8. 5, but sized up to a 9 based on other reviews. I actually wish I'd gone up to a 9. 5, but I'm assuming that the leather will stretch over time. Gorgeous boots, and I raked in compliments the first day I wore them."

Rikka W. (5/5)

Impossible to put on

"I am with the other reviewers on this is a Frye mistake. I cannot get my foot into these. What on earth?! Ofc I bought them on sale and Frye will tell me “sorry final sale”. I don’t even know whom to pass these on to. . they are seriously misdesigned - no way a foot slides into these."

Marcy (1/5)

I read the reviews and

"I read the reviews and ordered a whole size up but they were still small. My feet are pretty narrow so I figured one size up would be enough but unfortunately they were still too small. Design is nice, wished they weren’t so tall, kind of unflattering."

Emily A. (3/5)

HORRIBLE!! I completely understand finally

"HORRIBLE!! I completely understand finally sale and have purchased from FRYE before… what I don’t understand is out right misrepresentation. I wear a 7. 5, narrow to medium. I ordered an 8 due to boots often needing a sock and needing room. The boot labeled an 8 is a 6. 5, 7 at best! There’s NO WAY the published standards were honestly applied to the sizing of this boot. Yet, final sale … so no boot and no recourse via the return/exchange QR code. I’ve emailed 2 twice and zero customer service. Now they want a review!!!! HORRIBLE."

Laurie A. (1/5)

Beautiful Boot, however they are

"Beautiful Boot, however they are so tight in the toe area that I cant wear them. My size normally a 10B. I even ordered the next size up, I have them on a boot stretcher hoping they will stretch out."

Wanda W. (2/5)

Q&A