Overall rating: 3.7666667 / 5 from 30 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Astor Gore Slip-On combines richly textured vegetable tanned leather with a full rubber capsule and PORON footbed for style and comfort. While opinions on fit and leather vary, the look is a mixed bag with some finding it stylish and others less genuine.

Summary topics

  • Fit: 20%
  • Leather Comfort: 20%
  • Aesthetic Appeal: 24%

Review topics: [].

Review highlights

  • "I'm a 10 with a slimmer foot and they fit beautifully."Anthony P.
  • "I like the size style and fit"John
  • "Great fit and no break in period needed with or without socks!"James P.

Reviews

beautiful shoe, the leather looks

"beautiful shoe, the leather looks less genuine than I was hoping and expecting it to look because i bought the black pair of this shoe 2 years ago and the leather felt a bit more genuine/softer to the touch, but maybe the need tobe worked in a little more, the width is just a little on the narrow side, not horrible, but not perfect either."

Benjamin P. (5/5)

I bought a similar pair

"I bought a similar pair of these like 2 years ago and I kind of feel like the leather is slightly different, less genuine so to speak. I still need to break it in so maybe they'll get a bit looser and softer in the feel of the leather - but for now remains to be seen. Just a smidge narrow, but not in bad way."

Benjamin P. (5/5)

They are a bit tight

"They are a bit tight at the toes at present, may loosen up over time. Slightly wider would be more comfortable."

Ravishankar M. (4/5)

"I like the size style and fit"

John (5/5)

Almost perfect

"Great quality tight fit but will hopefully stretch a little"

Troy B. (4/5)

Uncomfortable

"They run very narrow and small. rough hard leather. uncomfortable"

Jered (1/5)

Great comfortable shoe right out

"Great comfortable shoe right out of the box! Great fit and no break in period needed with or without socks! Highly recommend!"

James P. (5/5)

The best quality of all

"The best quality of all the “Iranian Peasant” shoes out there. Narrow, but leather upper and leather liner stretch easily. Not quite as nice as they used to be, but then what is?"

Gregg A. (5/5)

They look nice but a

"They look nice but a little big and narrow. They don't feel as comfortable has my previous two Frye purchases."

Hung D. (2/5)

Perfect Slip On

"These split ons are simply perfect! They look and feel well made and make any outfit effortlessly cool and sophisticated. They run true to size. I'm a 10 with a slimmer foot and they fit beautifully. Highly recommend."

Anthony P. (5/5)

Q&A